I often make my own crackers. For this you need the cracker outline card (which I got from Amazon), a glue gun, cheap and nasty crackers, decorations such as ribbons, felt hearts and heart shaped buttons:
I made the present for inside by simply popping some sweeties into a gift bag and sealing using some festive ribbon:
Using cheap crackers, undo and reassemble your own, with own present and the hat, joke and cracker bit inside the cheap crackers. I used some thick ribbon and the glue gun to make sure the cracker was secure. I added the heart and button for decoration, again using glue gun:
Place one at each place setting.
Lovely, inexpensive and unique 🙂